Should rental payments be taken into account for mortgages?

We were surprised to learn that the government has recently rejected a petition which urged lenders to consider rental payments as proof of ability to meet mortgage repayments.

There was a great deal of support behind the petition which received over 100,000 signatures (therefore was considered for debate in Parliament).

Here at Poole Townsend, we regularly deal with first-time buyers and we understand the struggles and challenges they are faced with when it comes to getting that first step onto the property ladder. Therefore, we welcome and support any developments that will give them a helping hand when it comes to securing that first home.

The petition’s creator, Jamie Jack Pogson, says he wants “paying rent on time to be recognised as evidence that mortgage repayments can be met.” He says: “Since living on my own I have paid £70,000+ in rent on time yet still struggle to get a mortgage. Unless you're getting handouts, wealthy or in receipt of inheritance it's almost impossible.”

However the parliamentary debate came to the conclusion that lenders “must consider a range of factors when assessing a mortgage application”, adding that meeting rental payments is “not sufficient in itself” to demonstrate affordability over the lifetime of the loan.

In its response, the government said: “It is important to be aware that home ownership brings a number of additional expenses that may not be incurred when renting, including maintenance costs and buildings insurance. Before extending a loan, lenders must satisfy themselves that a borrower will be able to meet these additional ongoing costs when considering a mortgage application.

“Many lenders also use information from Credit Reference Agencies when considering mortgage applications. This is because previous customer behaviour, in terms of paying back debts, tends to be a relatively good predictor of future behaviour. Therefore if prospective borrowers have a history of good financial management it can improve their chances of obtaining credit.

“Beyond the FCA’s requirements, decisions around the availability of individual mortgage loans remain commercial decisions for lenders, and the government does not seek to intervene in these.

“Whilst one lender may be unable to offer a mortgage, being denied a mortgage from one provider does not preclude a customer from being offered credit elsewhere. There are a wide variety of mortgage products available in the UK and prospective borrowers may benefit from shopping around.”

While it’s a shame that the support of the 100,000 people who signed the petition has been ignored, we’re still hopeful that there are developments in the pipeline that will help first-time buyers in years to come. The positive side of this story is that the petition has raised awareness of the issue and has at least driven momentum towards the issue of the challenges that first-time buyers face. We would hope that this awareness will therefore lead to new ideas and solutions that will help young people wanting to buy their first home.

If you would like help and advice about getting on the property ladder for the first time, please don’t hesitate to get in touch with our friendly team or pop in for a brew and a chat to discuss your options.

You’re in safe hands

Trust our team of local experts to provide the best advice on a wide range of legal and financial issues whenever you’re facing a life change and need the best support.

0800 389 2939

Our team are available Monday to Friday 9am - 5pm

Find Your BranchMEET THE TEAM

She'll be glad you planned ahead

Organising your finances today, while planning for the future can be a challenge. We’ll put the kettle on – and take the pressure off.


You'll know when it's time to talk

From making a will, to matters of business law our qualified solicitors can offer advice and guidance. Pop in for a chat or call us to make your free appointment.


Sign up for our newsletter

Your details

Signing up to our newsletter will place you on our weekly property guide, providing you with the latest properties for sale and industry news.
You can unsubscribe at any time. We value your privacy and will not share your details.

© Poole Townsend 2017 - 2024. All rights reserved.
Poole Townsend solicitors Ltd (Company no:10964550) is a company registered in England and Wales with its registered office at 69-75 Duke Street, Barrow in Furness, LA14 1RP. A list of directors is available at the registered office address. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority number 647087. We are independent financial advisers authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. VAT registration number :154365563.

Poole Townsend Solicitors Ltd are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Poole Townsend Solicitors Ltd is entered on the Financial Services Register. under reference 807084.

Poole Townsend Estates Ltd. (Company number 10960705) is a company registered in England and Wales with its registereed office at 69-75 Duke Street, Barrow in Furness LA14 1RP. A list of directors is available at the registered office address. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority number 8004592. VAT Registration number 288092466. Our Estate Agency is a member of The Property Ombudsman Scheme.

Poole Townsend Estates Ltd Property Client account has client money protection, to view our Client Money Protection Certificate please click here. To view our Equality and Diversity Data please click here. The Propertymark Conduct and Membership Rules can be found here.

Professional Indemnity Insurance – please contact Martin Oates at the address above if you require details of cover held.

Registered with the Information Commissioners Office for data protection purposes (ICO No: ZA494153 & ZA331395)


Book Your Free Valuation

Fill out the form below and we'll get in touch to arrange your free valuation.

Your Details

We value your privacy and will not share your details.