State of independence

Our latest Law Talk with Martin...

A few weeks ago, I commented on warnings by Denzil Lush, recently retired senior judge, of the lack of safeguards surrounding Lasting Powers of Attorney. He said he would never sign one, citing an 83 year old, suffering from dementia, who gave an LPA to his neighbour, who then took money for his own use.

It turns out it is safer to be independent North of the border. Scotland’s Public Guardian, Sandra McDonald, said her inbox had "gone manic with Scottish lawyers anxious about what they say to reassure clients”. She pointed out the fundamental differences between LPAs north and south of the border.

The biggest difference in Scotland is that a proper assessment of capacity is required. A lawyer or doctor has to certify that the granter is aware of what it is, what powers they are granting and in whose favour, and that they are under no pressure to do so. This assessment is a critical safeguard. In England and Wales, the certification and witnessing is less prescriptive and so more open to abuse.

In our firm, we always assess and note our clients’ capacity. If there are any doubts, we involve a medical expert to go through the decisions and to assess capacity and then certify the LPA. This really protects the most vulnerable and should be a legal requirement here as it is in Scotland.

McDonald also said that the majority of LPAs in Scotland are drafted by solicitors following a detailed, private discussion between solicitor and granter. This legal involvement offers a significant protection. That is also how we would do it in our firm.

Thirdly, LPAs in Scotland are directive, i.e. powers are specific; the extent of the authority of the attorney is explicit. In England/Wales it is much more general although it can be limited if that is what you want.

In England/Wales, LPAs are too easy to do. You (or your naughty neighbour) can download the forms online, sort them all out and apply for registration. With no safeguards in place, you can see how easy it was for the neighbour in Lush’s example to get away with what he did.

So, for you or those close to you, see a lawyer to do it properly. It will cost more than DIY but it will be right and if there are challenges in future, the evidence will be there to support what you have done. If you know someone that you think is vulnerable, please bring them to see a lawyer to discuss it. Contact us here if you wish to book your free initial appointment.

You’re in safe hands

Trust our team of local experts to provide the best advice on a wide range of legal and financial issues whenever you’re facing a life change and need the best support.

0800 389 2939

Our team are available Monday to Friday 9am - 5pm

Find Your BranchMEET THE TEAM

She'll be glad you planned ahead

Organising your finances today, while planning for the future can be a challenge. We’ll put the kettle on – and take the pressure off.


You'll know when it's time to talk

From making a will, to matters of business law our qualified solicitors can offer advice and guidance. Pop in for a chat or call us to make your free appointment.


Sign up for our newsletter

Your details

Signing up to our newsletter will place you on our weekly property guide, providing you with the latest properties for sale and industry news.
You can unsubscribe at any time. We value your privacy and will not share your details.

© Poole Townsend 2017 - 2022. All rights reserved.
Poole Townsend solicitors Ltd (Company no:10964550) is a company registered in England and Wales with its registered office at 69-75 Duke Street, Barrow in Furness, LA14 1RP. A list of directors is available at the registered office address. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority number 647087. We are independent financial advisers authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. VAT registration number :154365563.

Poole Townsend Estates Ltd. (Company No: 10960705) is a company registered in England and Wales with its registered office at 69-75 Duke Street, Barrow in Furness LA14 1RP. A list of directors is available at the registered office address. Regulated by the Council of Licensed Conveyancers to provide Conveyancing services. (Firm no: 3438) VAT registration number 288092466. Our Estate Agency is a member of the Property Ombudsman scheme.

Poole Townsend Estates Ltd Property Client account has client money protection, to view our Client Money Protection Certificate please click here. To view our Equality and Diversity Data please click here. The Propertymark Conduct and Membership Rules can be found here.

Professional Indemnity Insurance – please contact Martin Oates at the address above if you require details of cover held.

Registered with the Information Commissioners Office for data protection purposes (ICO No: ZA494153 & ZA331395)


Book Your Free Valuation

Fill out the form below and we'll get in touch to arrange your free valuation.

Your Details

We value your privacy and will not share your details.